Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
 | 
Online Publication Date: 01 Dec 2006

Persistence of Fish Species Associations in Pools of a Small Stream of the Southern Great Plains

and
Page Range: 696 – 710
DOI: 10.1643/0045-8511(2006)6[696:POFSAI]2.0.CO;2
Save
Download PDF

Abstract

Persistence of direct contacts among species has important implications for the potential of taxa to influence each other's traits or evolutionary trajectories. We examined persistence of species (or “ecospecies”) associations in Brier Creek, Oklahoma, based on visual surveys on seven dates 1982–1983 and on 12 dates 1995–2003 in 14 contiguous pools. Fishes were considered to be associated, in direct contact, if they occurred within the same pool during a survey. Mantel tests showed that associations among 11 common taxa from survey to survey were highly variable, but were significantly concordant across 11 of 18 intervals between surveys. Most floods and droughts were not followed by decreased concordance of associations, but associations did change after the second of two very severe droughts (1998 and 2000). Within-year associations were highly concordant in 1983 and in 1996, years with the most repeated surveys. Patterns of association were highly concordant across years for surveys in late summer and episodically concordant for surveys in May 1995–2003, but not in autumn. A cluster analysis comparing all surveys showed that associations among taxa differed between earlier (1982–83) and later (1995–2003) surveys. For some subsets of taxa, we found strong, consistent association across most surveys.

Copyright: 2006 by the American Society of Ichthyologists and Herpetologists
Figure 1
Figure 1

Phenogram from SAHN clustering of a triangular matrix of Mantel Z-scores comparing concordance of all possible pairs of surveys.

Clusters are numbered to correspond with text of Results.


Figure 2
Figure 2

Phenograms from SAHN clustering of species associations within surveys based on Percent Similarity Index (PSI).

Shown are four of 19 phenograms constructed to examine subsets of species contributing to overall patterns of concordance of associations (see text). Species and “ecospecies” abbreviated as follows: LgBass  =  large Micropterus spp.; SmBass  =  small Micropterus spp.; LgBGL  =  large Bluegill; LgLongear  =  large Longear Sunfish; SmLongear  =  small Longear Sunfish; LgGreen  =  large Green Sunfish; SmGreen  =  small Green Sunfish; BigEyeShn  =  Bigeye Shiner; Bullhead  =  Ameiurus spp.; Topminnow  =  Blackstripe Topminnow; Stoneroller  =  Central Stoneroller.


Contributor Notes

(WJM) DEPARTMENT OF ZOOLOGY, UNIVERSITY OF OKLAHOMA, NORMAN, OKLAHOMA 73019;

Received: 09 May 2005
Accepted: 08 Jun 2006
  • Download PDF