Allozymic and Isozymic Evidence for Polytypy in the North American Catostomid Genus Cycleptus
To assess patterns of geographic variation in the wide-ranging North American catostomid genus Cycleptus, 23 specimens were obtained from six locations among four drainage systems that exit into the Gulf of Mexico. Starch gel electrophoresis was used to compare gene products of 47 loci. A contingency chi-square test showed that the 23 samples did not come from a single, random-breeding population. Tests using exact probabilities showed that all samples from within each of the four drainage systems were in agreement with Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium expectations. Pairwise combinations showed that only two of the drainages could be combined and still result in equilibrium. Three allopatric genetic units are recognized: (1) Rio Grande drainage, (2) Mississippi drainage, and (3) the Alabama plus Pascagoula drainages. All three units can be distinguished by differences in allelic composition at certain enzymatic loci, levels of heterozygosity, number of genes expressed (some genes have been silenced in these allotetraploids), and perhaps a regulatory character involving mMdhp-A1. We propose that these units be recognized as separate species. The Mississippi drainage population would retain the name Cycleptus elongatus (Lesueur). The Gulf Coast population has recently been described as Cycleptus meridionalis Burr and Mayden. The Rio Grande population awaits further analysis of morphological and molecular variation and a formal description.Abstract

Expression of G3pdh-A gene products in muscle extracts from Cycleptus. A single gene product (G3pdh-A2) is expressed in specimens from the Rio Grande drainage (lanes 1–5); two gene products (G3pdh-A1 and G3pdh-A2) are expressed in specimens from the Alabama River system (lanes 6–8). (A) Separation of products using EBT buffer (Wilson et al., 1973). (B) Separation of products using Histidine-citrate buffer, pH 8.0 (Brewer, 1970)

Expression of mMdhp-A gene products in muscle extracts of Cycleptus. A single gene product (mMdhp-A2) is expressed in specimens from the Rio Grande drainage (lanes 1–3), the Wabash River (lanes 4–5), the Big Sunflower River (lane 6), and the Missouri River (lane 8); two gene products (mMdhp-A1 and mMdhp-A2) are expressed in specimens from the Alabama River (lanes 9–12) and the Pascagoula River (lane 13). See text for additional discussion

Expression of glucose-6-phosphate isomerase in muscle extracts of Cycleptus. A single homodimeric gene product (Gpi-B2) is expressed in specimens from the Rio Grande drainage (lanes 1–5); two homodimeric products (Gpi-B1 and Gpi-B2) are expressed in specimens from the Alabama River system (lanes 6–12). Specimens 11 and 12 are heterozygous at the Gpi-A1 locus