The Interactive Effects of Fish Predation and Conspecific Density on Survival and Growth of Tadpoles of Rana sylvatica in a Subarctic Wetland
In nature, prey are often simultaneously exposed to predators and competitors, leading to conflicting demands between survival and growth. Larval amphibians are model organisms to investigate the balancing of life history trade-offs because individuals must metamorphose before a wetland dries. Therefore, we deployed enclosures in a natural wetland to investigate the interactive effects of Wood Frog (Rana sylvatica) density (50 or 100 tadpoles) and Brook Stickleback (Culaea inconstans) presence on survival and growth of tadpoles. We hypothesized that the effects of conspecific density on tadpole survival and growth would be dependent on the presence of fish predators. Stickleback predation significantly decreased Wood Frog survival; however, a trend of higher tadpole survival with fish was detected at high conspecific densities. Wood Frog time to and mass at metamorphosis was not significantly affected by either conspecific density or stickleback presence. Our results demonstrate that Brook Sticklebacks can play a significant role in regulating Wood Frog survival in a Subarctic wetland, but the impact is likely dependent on tadpole density. Therefore, this research highlights the dynamic and complex effects of competition and predation in a Subarctic wetland. Our study also contributes to the limited understanding of factors affecting amphibian community structure in Subarctic wetlands.

Mean proportion of surviving Wood Frog (Rana sylvatica) tadpoles among four experimental treatments. Treatments are listed under each bar: low, no fish = 50 tadpoles; high, no fish = 100 tadpoles; low, fish = 50 tadpoles with one Brook Stickleback; and high, fish = 100 tadpoles with one Brook Stickleback. Proportion surviving is measured as the absolute value of the instantaneous per capita rate at which sticklebacks kill R. sylvatica. Means are pooled from replicates. Error bars represent ±1 SE.

Mean mass at metamorphosis (in grams) of surviving Wood Frog tadpoles among four experimental treatments. Treatments are listed under each bar: low, no fish = 50 tadpoles; high, no fish = 100 tadpoles; low, fish = 50 tadpoles with one Brook Stickleback; and high, fish = 100 tadpoles with one Brook Stickleback. Means are pooled from replicates. Error bars represent ±1 SE.
Contributor Notes
Associate Editor: J. Kerby.